Split rail fence has an enduring charm and is suitable for farms, rural sites, parks and residential settings. If you do want to construct one, you likely have looked for split cedar fence rails as it has long been a popular fencing material. But, the need for greater durability and service life of materials, combined with reduced maintenance costs, has made black locust a more appealing option for property owners.
In this guide, we are going to take a look at split cedar fence rails vs black locust fence rails, so that you can understand which type is the most economical, durable and attractive fence rail option for your next fence project.
Why split fence rails are so popular.
Split cedar fence rails have been a popular fence rail material for decades due to their rustic appearance and natural resistance to decay. The oils in the wood of cedar are naturally present and will help to ward off insects and moisture, and will make it more durable than many softwoods.
Cedar is a natural fit for outdoor spaces and a homeowner favorite. Cedar fences will look great around country homes, horse pasture or garden.
The other benefit is that cedar is light and easy to install as compared to many dense hardwoods.
The Cedar’s Limits
Cedar is a softwood, but it does not have the same issues of performance as untreated pine. Exposure to heavy rain, snow, strong sun, and temperature fluctuation on a long-term basis can impact its look and durability.
Common problems are:
- Surface cracking
- Gradual weathering
- Wear from impacts
- Shortened life in moist conditions
These are not reasons why cedar isn’t a good choice, but if you want a fenced area that will last for several decades and requires very little maintenance, these factors should be taken into account.
Why Black Locust Is Becoming a Preferred Alternative
Black locust is one of the most resistant hardwoods in North America. The black locust is naturally decay resistant and resistant to insects and fungi, while chemically treated lumber is not.
Due to these natural characteristics black locust has been traditionally employed in:
- Fence posts
- Agricultural fencing
- Railroad ties
- Vineyard supports
- Outdoor construction
Today, companies such as Black Locust Lumber are carrying on the tradition, creating top-of-the-range fencing products that perform admirably in outdoor environments.
Durability Comparison
Durability is a major consideration when you consider split cedar fence rails vs. black locust.
Black locust is much denser than cedar and will stand years of weathering without being worn as much. Also much harder, which means it is more resistant to dents, scratches and heavy impacts.
Black locust usually has a longer service life in areas with severe winters, high temperatures or heavy precipitation.
Maintenance Requirements
Another factor to note when selecting fence materials is maintenance.
Periodic sealing or staining is beneficial to the cedar if you wish to retain its original colour. It is a natural silver-gray color over time if not treated.
When left untreated, Black Locust also acquires a nice gray color, but it can withstand the elements and remains structurally sound with minimal maintenance.
Black locust is therefore an attractive option for those wishing to have a fence that requires little maintenance.
Appearance and Design
Cedar and black locust are both very attractive natural features.
These split cedar fence rails are lighter in color than smooth, leave the grain showing and have a classic rustic look that is perfect for traditional landscapes.
Black locust will usually be golden brown in color, with tighter grain. This gives it a beautiful, silver-gray appearance as it matures, while retaining its strength.
Either material can be used to improve the landscape around a country estate, vineyard, public park or residential property.
Sustainability Matters
Sustainability is now an important consideration in the design and construction of our infrastructure and environment.
Domestic hardwood that grows quickly and regenerates readily, black locust is an environmentally sound choice. It also has an outstanding durability, which means that there will be a lower amount of material used over time because of the reduced need for replacements.
Black Locust Lumber highlights the importance of sustainable forests and quality wood products.
One of the easiest methods to minimize long-term environmental impact is to use long-lasting materials.
Cost vs Long-Term Value
It seems as though many consumers start looking at fencing materials based on the price they will pay for the fence itself.
Split cedar fence rails may be cheaper in the short term but when all costs are considered it is not the case.
A fence that needs fewer repairs, less maintenance and fewer replacements may prove to be the better investment in the long run.
However, the durability of black locust often outweighs its initial price, making it a sound investment for those looking for a long-term solution.
Choosing the Right Material
The type of fencing you want will be determined by your needs.
If you prefer to use split cedar fence rails, you should:
- Opt for a traditional rustic look
- Need lightweight rails
- Can easily carry out routine maintenance tasks
If you choose, select black locust:
- Exceptional durability
- Inherently decay and insect resistant.
- Minimal maintenance
- Long-term cost savings
- Sustainable hardwood performance
Why Choose Black Locust Lumber?
With high-quality fencing products, the quality is as important as the type of wood.
Black Locust Lumber offers quality black locust products in residential, agricultural, commercial and landscape applications. They use a natural hardwood, carefully selected for its natural durability, strength and longevity.
If you’re looking for a new fence installation or replacing an old fence, installing an excellent quality hardwood will provide you with good fence performance for many years.
Final Thoughts
Split cedar fence rails are still in use for their natural beauty and classic look, but black locust has definite benefits for the property owner who wants the highest possible durability and maintenance-free fence.
It is one of the most resistant hardwoods to rot, insect damage and extreme weather conditions to be used for exterior fence work. This, along with its life and sustainability, makes black locust a top fencing material.
When considering a fence that will stand the test of time, Black Locust Lumber offers reliable hardwood fencing that is both useful and beautiful. From farms to homes, parks to businesses, a big investment in quality materials now equals decades of dependable service.